Blog
How to Rank in Google AI Overviews: Our Test
Half of the web pages Google AI Overviews cited in our test did not rank on page 1 for the same search, and about a third weren’t on page 2 either. A page-1 ranking was neither required nor enough: the #1 organic result was cited in only 5 of 14 AI Overviews. What kept showing up in our test were YouTube videos and Reddit threads.
On November 3, 2026, we ran 16 US searches on google.com: 8 informational, 6 commercial and 2 service questions. For each one, we logged every source the AI Overview linked to and checked whether those pages ranked on page 1 or page 2 of the same results. Fifteen searches showed an AI Overview, and 14 of those listed sources, 142 links in all.
Do you need to rank on page 1 to get cited?
No. Set the videos aside and the AI Overviews cited 94 web pages: 47 (50%) ranked on page 1 of the same results, 15 (16%) on page 2 and 32 (34%) on neither page.
Ranking still helps: 48% of the page-1 web results were cited (47 of 98), against 12% of the page-2 results (15 of 124). But a page-1 spot was not the entry ticket.
In 12 of the 14 AI Overviews, at least one cited page came from outside page 1. Only the answers on cleaning a cast iron skillet and running shoes for flat feet took all their web pages from page 1.
The search for this article’s topic makes the point. The AI Overview for “how to rank in google ai overviews” told readers to win classic organic rankings before anything else, under the heading “Win Traditional Organic Rankings First.” Yet of the six web pages it cited, five weren’t on page 1. Search Engine Journal, Ahrefs and SEOCrawl ranked on page 2. TripleDart and Rank Math weren’t on either page.
For “what is generative engine optimization,” 5 of the 7 cited pages ranked on neither page, while Wikipedia (#1) and Search Engine Land (#2) weren’t cited. Ranking and getting cited overlap, but they’re not the same job.
Does ranking #1 get you into the AI Overview?
Not reliably. The #1 organic result was cited in 5 of the 14 AI Overviews with sources.
Reddit shows the gap best. A Reddit thread ranked #1 in 9 of the 14 searches, and that thread was cited in only 2 of the 9. Yet Reddit appeared in 10 of the 14 AI Overviews, often through a different thread. For “best crm for small business,” r/crmsoftware ranked #1 and the citation went to r/crm.
It looks like the AI Overviews wanted a Reddit voice but picked the thread themselves. Reddit was the clearest case of third-party sources in this test.
How much do videos count?
A lot. 46 of the 142 source links (32%) were YouTube videos or Shorts, and 2 more were Facebook or LinkedIn videos. YouTube appeared in 13 of the 14 AI Overviews with sources.
For “how to clean a cast iron skillet,” 8 of the 11 sources were videos.
What happens on commercial searches?
On some of them, the obvious candidates got skipped and the sources got stranger.
For “best crm for small business,” none of the 8 page-1 results was cited, including HubSpot, Salesforce and Forbes Advisor. The AI Overview cited 5 YouTube videos, PCMag and Zoho (both from page 2), the r/crm thread and an agency blog that ranked on neither page.
“Best project management software for small teams” pulled 21 sources, including a podcasting subreddit thread, Asana’s App Store listing from the Jordan storefront and a LinkedIn personal profile. Only 2 of its 17 cited web pages ranked on page 1, and none on page 2. The answer attached small source chips to individual claims, like one tool’s free-tier limit. It looks like it sourced each claim from wherever that claim was written down.
Vendors can still win. For “best payroll software for small business,” 4 of the 8 cited pages were the vendors’ own: Gusto, Patriot Software, QuickBooks and Paychex. For “hubspot vs salesforce for small business,” both companies’ comparison pages ranked on page 1, and neither was cited.
Does every search get an AI Overview?
No. “Best espresso machine under 500” showed no AI Overview. Google showed a shopping layout with product filters instead.
“How much does it cost to replace a roof” got a full cost breakdown, with a national range of $6,700 to $13,000 and prices by material, but zero linked sources. It ended by asking about material, square footage and region. On a reload a few minutes later, the “most homeowners pay” figure had moved from about $9,300 to about $9,000.
So how do you rank in Google AI Overviews?
Each step comes from what we saw in this test.
- Check that your query triggers one. One of our 16 searches showed no AI Overview, and another cited no sources. Search it yourself before you build for it.
- Don’t write off your page-2 pages. 15 cited pages came from page 2 and 32 from neither page. A page that isn’t on page 1 yet is still a candidate.
- Publish a video that answers the question. YouTube was in 13 of 14 AI Overviews and supplied 46 of 142 links.
- State your product facts on your own pages, and check the roundups. Payroll vendors’ own pages took 4 of 8 citations. But in the project management answer, the chip for one tool’s free-tier limit pointed to Zapier’s roundup, not to the vendor’s site. Put pricing, limits and features in plain, citable text on your site, and check that the roundups covering your category state them correctly.
- Get discussed in the Reddit threads on your topic. Reddit was in 10 of 14 AI Overviews, but the #1 Reddit thread was cited in just 2 of 9 cases. Being in several threads looks more useful than owning the one that ranks.
- Check the AI Overview, not just your rank. The #1 result was cited in 5 of 14. A top position doesn’t tell you whether you’re in the answer.
What this test can’t tell you
This is a snapshot: one load per search (plus the roof reload), on one day, from a signed-in Google account with personalized results off, over a connection from outside the US. A US user could see a different AI Overview. We matched exact URLs, so a cited page counts as unranked even if another page on the same site ranked. Page 1 held only 5 to 9 organic links per search, because AI Overviews, videos, forums and People Also Ask took the space. Sixteen searches show patterns, not rules, which is why AI share of voice is measured across many runs.
Frequently asked questions
Do you need to rank on page 1 to appear in Google AI Overviews?
No. In Sourcelift’s November 3, 2026 test of 16 US searches, half of the 94 web pages cited in AI Overviews were not on page 1 of the same results: 15 ranked on page 2 and 32 on neither page.
Does ranking #1 on Google get you cited in AI Overviews?
Not reliably. The #1 organic result was cited in 5 of 14 AI Overviews in our test. A Reddit thread ranked #1 in 9 searches and was cited in only 2 of them.
How important is YouTube for Google AI Overviews?
Very, in our test. YouTube appeared in 13 of 14 AI Overviews with sources and accounted for 46 of 142 source links.
Does every Google search show an AI Overview?
No. One of our 16 searches, best espresso machine under 500, showed a shopping layout instead. Another, on the cost of replacing a roof, showed an AI Overview with no linked sources.
See what AI Overviews cite for your questions
Before you rewrite pages or record videos, check what AI Overviews cite for your buyers’ questions. Our free AI visibility diagnosis runs those questions through Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity, and shows where you show up and where you don’t. If you want the work done for you, that’s our AI search optimization service. For the other big engine, see how to rank in ChatGPT.